I bought my 3 door DSG with the following options, Metallic Black paint, Bi-Zenon lights, leather interior, central armrest, multi-function steering wheel, 18" alloys and climate control. I have had the car three months now and put 9,000 kilometers on the clock. Overall the car has been fantastic to own. Ok so it wasn't cheap to buy at €44,700 but if you look at other cars for the same money and offering similar performance, fuel economy, reliability, comfort, practicality and resale value, there are little or no equivalents. The BMW 123d is one but you either love or hate the look of it and in my opinion is a bit boring looking albeit with better fuel economy. Everything in the Autocar review is true about this car however i disagree with their opinion on the brakes. Mine has super responsive brakes with decent feel when pushed hard. Ok so I have never brought my car on a track day so can't comment on them when pushed to the limit but in everyday life they are brilliant. They are better than any of my previous cars which include a Peugoet 106 GTI and new Mini Cooper. I use my car for work and can honestly say my only bad comment on the car is the 18" wheels. They look fantastic and some would say you can't buy a GTI without them but they are a bit hard over badly surfaced roads and we have plenty of them here in Ireland! Don't get me wrong, I have owned several cars worse in terms of comfort, in particular my BMW 318 m-pack but I can't help but thinking I should have stuck with the standard 17" ones. In saying that, the car does look great on them and they first struck me as being nearly as comfortable as my last car, a Lexus IS200 Sport but as time has gone on, I have started to get a bit more irritated with them.
In summary, if you are thinking of buying a GTI just go for it. I took three months to decide and have never looked back. Overall it is a brilliant all round car and the only decision you should have is 3 door or 5. Happy motoring.