Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Tue
Dec 18 2007

The rot won't stop until Ron's gone

Andrew Frankel

Who among us thinks Ron Dennis should stay in his job? Ron Dennis for one, who on Sunday announced in the News of the World that he was not going to quit because "I do not think it would be in the best interests of the team." How much more proof do we need of how far out of touch he has become?

If any normal British business was found in possession of that much illicitly acquired information belonging to its closest rival, its chief executive would not need to be sacked because, in all likelihood, he’d have reached for his hat and coat on the day he first became aware of it. Yet Dennis continues despite the fact that, far from the information belonging to just one rogue employee as originally stated, it had clearly become much more widely disseminated throughout his organisation. And despite his protestations that there was no way any of this information could possibly have been used in the design of any McLaren, we now hear that, according to Autosport, "Ferrari-inspired parts were being considered for their 2008 car", eliciting an apology to the FIA and Ferrari that would have carried substantially more weight if it had been issued sooner.

Personally, I don’t doubt that Dennis told the truth, inasmuch as he knew it, from start to finish, and I believe entirely that he had no hand in all the ghastly goings-on that have clearly occurred during 2007. But not knowing is not good enough – the fact remains that he should have known. Indeed, given the breadth and depth of the scandal, it seems almost incredible that something involving so many senior people over such a long period of time could possibly have transpired without his knowledge. But it appears it has. That lack of knowledge has helped damage the team’s reputation around the world, and we’ll only know next spring how much it has damaged the team from within. It seems barely believable that it can have had no effect on the performance of the 2008 car.

We all know where the buck is meant to stop in organisations such as McLaren, but until Dennis steps up and steps down, I fear it’s going to continue smashing its way through the most successful British F1 team in history. No one person is bigger than that.

Technorati tags: , , ,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Andrew Frankel

Talents are limited to "driving cars and writing English." In 19th century France he would, therefore, have been stuffed; as it is, Andrew's the perfect Autocar road test writer.

Comments

audilyy December 18, 2007 3:38 PM

Watching from the outposts of television and newspint it always seems Ron is always playing the PR hand, spinning his way around a web of cunning half truths. He plays a slick hand,  with a poker face which you just know is hiding far more than it reveals.  But isn't that F1 all over?

Neil J December 18, 2007 10:14 PM

Does this mean that Flavio at Renault should also stand down? Despite the FIA's protestations, Renault would appear to be just as guilty of spying, what with McLaren's data being found on many of their computers.

Are we also to believe that the transfer of info between Ferrari and McLaren was one way? What would the FIA find if they were to investigate Ferrari's '08 race car?

Then again, for the sake of the "sport", perhaps it's best that the whole sorry business is put to bed so that we can look forward to seeing Alonso being thrashed by yet another rookie team mate!

audilyy December 19, 2007 3:05 PM

Despite the FIA's protestions Flavio should stand down because he should know better, those jeans wouldn't look right on Naomi Campbell!

Ducatidave February 29, 2008 7:39 PM

Thank You Mr Frankel, always did like your comments.

I wrote a similar thing on your forum last year and received a load of abuse from readers.

I differ from you in that I strongly believe he did know what was going, which is why he goes on about his integrity. And, like you say, if he did not then he is incompetent and Mercedes must surely ask what else he has no knowledge about that happens at Mclaren.

It really angers me that people like Alan Henry dont feel the same, I can't see how else the situation can be viewed.

Can you imagine the press reports if it had been Flavio Briatore who'd been accused...or if Michael Schumacher had gained the benefit of Mclaren knowledge? The British press would have wanted them both banned for life. Different story for Ron and Lewis though eh?!

AutoUnionMan March 16, 2008 9:38 PM

I am sorry but Ron Dennis is always going to have more integrity than almost any other team principal in the pit lane no matter what he knew or did not know. (I simply do not believe than Briatore or Todt have not at some point in the [recent] past done the same or a similar thing).

The blatent way that the information was being dealt with suggests to me that it is common practice and the only crime that McClaren committed was to get caught, at which point they had to be seen to be punished.

The reality of the punishment is that Mclaren will not go into the record books as having won the constructors title (when everyone knows that they did) and Raikkonen was gifted the drivers title (that rightfully belongs to Hamilton).

The fine obviously having virtualy no effect on the teams ability to go about it's business.

But surely it is near impossible to stop this exchange of information, especially when a designer moves from one team to another, indeed all seriously good inovations eventualy end up being adopted by all the teams.

Or perhaps all the other teams should have been banned from using side skirts once Colin Chapman had put them on the Lotus 78?

Where do you draw the line?

COLES June 27, 2008 11:16 PM

AutoUnionMan

Irrespective of individual believes the facts speak for themselves. When this first kicked off RD was interviewed on TV blabbing on about McLarens integrity, it was just one rouge employee, a kroll investigation proved McLaren's innocence etc...

When the FIA investigated senior McLaren management & other designers were found to be well aware of the dossier, discussed certain areas in detail, tested Ferrari set up's (Alonso & Pedro) on track & in the simulator and were told what lap Kimi would pit for fuel at the first race in Oz.

Mr integrity must of known, dug himself into a hole that he could not get out of and then issued a statement confirming the fact that senior management knew from the beginning signed by Martin Whitmarsh, his second in command!

After the fine was given it was also said that the 2008 car designs would be checked if it contained any Ferrari IP. It did. The fine covered just the 2007 shenanigans. Curiously the findings on the 2008 car didn't have any serious consequences, it's clearly a cop out. Not to mention that it is not enough to check only the car designs like the FIA did; you really need to check a lot more than that. But it was just a show to appease the public, to make it look like justice would be handed out. In reality business interests were much more important, just like they were when McL were allowed to keep all their (fake) 2007 results and keep on racing. In what other sport can a team be caught like that and still be allowed to keep competing? This is what I wrote on that topic earlier:

I don't think that's the case. Like with the MP4-23 designs where they picked some random systems to check, and then found evidence of stolen Ferrari IP used in their design, I think the 22 was also checked only partially. The FIA probably don't have the time or the resources to "comb upside down" a car really. The amazing thing is that all McL got for being found out in using Ferrari IP in the design of the 23 is that they merely can't develop those things for a while now. It is like an athlete being caught using doping and being told that he can't use the particular doping substance that he was caught with, but other than that he can compete and maybe even use other types of doping. Appalling, not to mention unsporting and unfair for all other teams.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Autocar 1 Oct 2008

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>