Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Mon
May 12 2008

Dealers play recession roulette

Mike Duff

If you’re calling about the car, it’s already gone. Selling my 2001 Seat Toledo TDI has delivered a fascinating insight into the dynamics of the modern car market. Main dealers might be filled with tumbleweed and racks of yellowing brochures, but demand for sub-£3000 diesels invokes an analogy concerning hot cakes.

Indeed, despite 93,000 miles and a reasonable crop of stone chips, my Toledo sold to the first punter to come and see it – for just £150 less than the keen price I was asking for it. I’m not surprised: soaring fuel prices mean that a realistic 48mpg is hugely compelling at the bottom end of the market.

IMG_0594 

But, before it departed, the Toledo also delivered an insight into just why the modern car showroom is echoing to little more than the sound of glum-looking sales executives’ shuffling feet.

Like most punters at car-change time, my first thought was to offload the trusty Seat as a part-ex. And, to cut a long story short, my local Honda dealership offered me just £1100 for it: considerably less than half of what I eventually got, and barely 50 per cent of it’s official trade value according to the industry-standard CAP price guide.

I can only presume that the logic was that, having spent two hours in the dealership getting as far as the derisory offer, I’d meekly roll over and accept it. Of course, I walked: turning the whole thing into a waste of everyone’s time.

Granted, the dealership might not want to have been lumbered with a car it couldn’t sell through its own used approved scheme. But a mate who knows these things assures me there’s no problem getting older diesels “underwritten” for their trade value these days.

In short, a very odd way to (not) do business. And now I’m in the happy position of being a cash-only purchaser, I won’t be heading back to this dealership any time soon.

Technorati Tags: ,,,,,,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Mike Duff

The incoming editor of autocar.co.uk started life in radio news, but found doorstepping bereaved mothers too much like hard work and opted to scribble about cars instead. He joined Autocar in 2007 and reckons that big-engined diesels are the future.

Comments

jbroadis May 13, 2008 12:47 PM

Couldn't agree more regarding the market demand for small/medium diesel and modest capacity petrol cars. I found this out recently when trying to trade in my 2004 Toledo. Except mine was a V5 (2.3l 170bhp). In many ways a desirable car with a great spec (part leather/alcantara, colour sat nav, elec seats etc.) but it soon became apparent that very few dealers would touch it as a part ex. The message was clear that clean 1.6 petrols and diesels fly off the forecourt, whereas a 2.3 petrol will sit, and sit, and sit....

In the end I got an OK price at a local SEAT dealer as a part-ex on a new Leon FR TFSI. That was three months ago, and my old Toledo is still there on the forecourt despite a £500 reduction. I wonder if it will still be there in 3 months time - I expect so.

The great news is that if you don't mind paying a bit more on road tax and fuel (my Toledo still averaged 31mpg) there are some fantastic used bargains out there.

Quattro369 May 14, 2008 12:00 AM

Im almost always insulted by the low prices dealers offer for a Part-Ex. Years ago i bought a Vauxhall Corsa for £6650.

My circumstances changed and approx 2 months (& 1,000 miles) later I asked the dealer how much it would offer me to hande the vehicle back. The offer was £4900. I was desperate and so after they agreed to up the offer to £5k i accepted.

I went past a week later and saw the car for sale at the bargain price of... Yup. £6650! What a joke!

kerrecoe June 5, 2008 1:20 PM

We just got offered £1500 below the trade price for our 56 Punto Sporting, as recommended by What Car's Valuation service, as a trade in for a new 500 Lounge. Needless to say we didn't accept the dealers offer.  and he missed out on a sale.

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Autocar 26 Nov

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>